On a recent broadcast, NPR noted that early education is making news — thanks in large part to President Obama’s $75 billion proposal to expand preschool for 4-year-olds.
“The problem,†NPR quotes Obama saying, “is that we’re still not reaching enough kids.†According to NPR, state-run preschool programs only reach 30 percent of eligible children.
Congress isn’t listening to the president, NPR’s Claudio Sanchez saidd, but states are. Many have expanded their preschool programs, and others are planning to grow. This raises a key question: What is high-quality preschool program? What, specifically, is it about the best programs that make a difference in children’s lives?
For answers, NPR turns to Deborah Phillips, a developmental psychologist and professor at Georgetown University, who studies early education.
“What you’re going to look for,” Phillips told NPR, “is a teacher who knows how to instruct children in pre-math, pre-literacy, who gets down on the child’s level when talking to them, who’s respectful towards them.”
Phillips found that kind of excellence in Tulsa, Okla., where she and her academic team spent seven months observing teachers across the city. Phillips found “four pillars of quality:†strong curriculum, strong funding, balanced teacher-student ratios, and highly qualified teachers.
Phillips says Tulsa’s program is well-funded, at $7,500 per child. The teacher/student ratio is 1:10. Teachers must have a bachelor’s degree and certification in early childhood education. And they earn a respectable salary, about $42,000 per year.
The program also has a lasting impact on children. “The children who went through Tulsa pre-K, compared to those who didn’t, are doing better in math,” Phillips told NPR. “That’s especially true for boys and lower-income children.”
Doing well in math is important. A 2012 study found that preschool-through-12th-grade math achievement was a good predictor of whether students would stay on track and attend two- or four-year colleges.
The challenges of offering high-quality programs are considerable, Tulsa preschool teacher Nikki Jones told NPR. “You’re asking kids to do things they’ve never done before. They’ve never been in school before, never raised their hand and stood up and given an answer before. So it’s scary to them.”
Some children are also grappling with hunger, poverty or parents who are incarcerated.
Phillips says that high-quality preschool teachers do some of the things that parents do. An excellent teacher “provides strong emotional, social support for children, makes them feel safe, protected, loved, valued.” This makes children feel motivated. “They love school. We’re setting children along a much sturdier, promising pathway into their futures.”
While Tulsa is successful, other preschool programs around the country struggle. They may be inadequately funded or unregulated. And children who don’t enroll in high-quality programs can be caught in a “spiral of failure:†inadequate investment in early education, followed by grade school efforts that aren’t sufficient enough to help children make up for lost educational time, as W. Steven Barnett told NPR. Barnett is the executive director of NIEER (the National Institute for Early Education Research).
Tulsa isn’t alone. Researchers say that Boston, New Jersey, Georgia, and other cities and states also have high-quality programs. All these efforts help set a standard, one that the entire country should meet to help all children thrive.

